This page outlines a number of tools that can be used in the different phases of the process of developing a shadow report.
Outline of a shadow report
The following report outline is based on the outline of the SDG 16 toolkit of the TAP Network1. It provides guidelines of the different components that could be included in a shadow report on SDG 16.10.
Outline
- Executive summary
- Introduction
- Background and context to the report
- Overview of methodology and data collection process
- Review of Legal and Legislative Framework and Policies
- Brief introduction
- Assessment of frameworks and policies on access to information and safety of journalists
- Challenges and recommendations
- Review of Country-level Implementation of SDG 16.10
- Brief introduction
- Assessment of progress, presentation of data
- Challenges and recommendations
- Review of International Commitments made by country (if applicable)
- Assessment of progress
- Challenges and recommendations
- Civil Society participation in SDG Implementation / Follow-up
- Assessment of civil society space around the SDGs (and in general)
- Challenges and recommendations
- Conclusions
- Conclusions
- Recommendations
- Annexes
- List of Organizations Consulted
- Data Sets
- National Development Plans or Frameworks
- Other Sources (if applicable)
Shadow report checklist
Preparation
- Check if your government has volunteered for a VNR
- Reach out to government to understand how to engage in VNR process
- Define goal and target of shadow report
- Allocate time and resources to the process
- Map relevant stakeholders
- Reach out to relevant civil society organizations and other stakeholders and form coalitions
Data Collection
- Select indicators to monitor
- Develop methodology and ensure that there is a shared understanding of the methodology and indicators
- Ensure that perspectives from under-represented and marginalized groups are included
- Verify the information received
- Consult with other organizations and government entities where possible
Report
- Present information in a clear and concise way
- Highlight positive and negative aspects of the implementation of SDG 16.10
- Formulate constructive and realistic recommendations
Follow up
- Ensure that the report is published online and publicly available
- Try to participate in HLPF, through government or by organizing a side-event
- Implement advocacy strategy to raise awareness for findings of shadow report
- Advocate for the follow up of recommendations and commitments of VNR process
Advocacy resources
Within the pages of the Media Advocacy Resource Guide a number of useful resources are provided on the page Advocacy Tools and M&E to plan, implement and evaluate advocacy strategies and multi-stakeholder processes. The guide includes:
- Stakeholder analysis tools
- Guidelines on formulating an advocacy strategy
- Management of multi-stakeholder processes
- Guidelines of monitoring and evaluation of advocacy
Resources and toolkits on developing shadow reports
- The SDG16+ Civil Society Toolkit by TAP Network, especially the sections on Voluntary National Reviews and Civil Society Spotlight Reports
- Mainstreaming SDG 16: Using the Voluntary National Review to Advance More Peaceful, Just and Inclusive Societies, by Global Alliance and TAP Network. This resource provides policy guidance and case studies on advancing SDG 16 implementation at national and subnational levels by more effectively leveraging VNR and post-VNR processes.
- SDG 16 Toolkit by GPPAC with a flow chart that guides you to different resources, from how to design an advocacy strategy to where to find the governmental SDG focal point in your country.
Examples of shadow reports on SDG 16.10
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10.1 in Colombia, La FundaciĆ³n para la Libertad de Prensa (FLIP), 2021
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10.1 in Indonesia, Independent Journalist Association (AJI), 2021
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10.1 in Pakistan, Pakistan Press Foundation (PPF), 2021
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10.2 in four African countries, African Freedom of Information Centre (AFIC), 2021
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10 in Asia, International Press Institute (IPI), 2021
- Shadow Report on SDG 16.10.1 in Latin America, Voces del Sur, 2021
- Synthesis Report SDG 16.10, Free Press Unlimited (FPU), 2021
1For more elaborate guidelines on what to include in each section of the report, consult the TAP Network Reporting Guidelines at https://tapnetwork2030.org/sdg16reporting/.